The Pan-European Journal
Back to Essays
Tätervolk: The Birth of Post-War Germany's National Ethos

Tätervolk: The Birth of Post-War Germany's National Ethos

Tim WinterlingJuly 25, 202610 min read
Share:

In Germany, mainstream politicians have reacted with alarm to studies suggesting that fewer and fewer young Germans feel guilty about the Second World War. This is hardly surprising, given that they have no personal connection to it.

Among German citizens with a migrant background, this sense of inherited guilt is even less pronounced. This presents a genuine challenge to an older political class whose understanding of Germany as a nation is fundamentally rooted in the Holocaust as the defining expression of Germany, the German people, and their history.

As a result, younger generations becoming increasingly resistant to being guilt-tripped over crimes they never committed borders on treason in the eyes of many within the political establishment, because it challenges the very foundation of their conception of German national identity.

An even more striking example was the reaction to demonstrators in Berlin chanting, ‘Free Gaza from German guilt.’ Many mainstream parties and politicians responded with shock and outrage. Some were quick to call for severe measures against those involved, including the denaturalisation of migrants, effectively seeking to exclude them from their conception of the German nation.

Yet when it comes to social media posts criticising Israel, even moderate CDU politicians have at times adopted positions that critics characterise as resembling a ‘blood and soil’ conception of national belonging, only to argue in other contexts that denaturalisation is unconstitutional when ‘new Germans’ commit serious crimes, while simultaneously maintaining that advocating denaturalisation and remigration should place an individual under observation by the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution.

This apparent contradiction is rooted, I argue, in a conception of the German nation as the eternal Tätervolk (‘nation of perpetrators’). German history education is often structured in such a way that the Holocaust becomes the culmination of the national narrative. The history of Germany before 1933 is thus interpreted as a long march towards the Holocaust, viewed as the outcome of Prussian militarism, German nationalism, historical forms of antisemitism, and a broader culture of political indifference.

As a consequence, some Germans have come to believe that becoming careless about the Holocaust could pave the way for the return of German nationalism and militarism. Public rituals of remembrance and self-criticism serve, in part, to remind Germans of what they are believed to be capable of if they fail to keep themselves ‘in check’.

Some readers will probably have encountered unusual comments by Germans on social media whenever contemporary war crimes or mass killings of civilians are discussed. Germans sometimes insert themselves into these conversations as self-appointed ‘genocide experts’, citing their own history as the basis for their authority.

In this sense, the years from 1933 to 1945 function not only as Germany’s original sin but also as a new founding myth. Paradoxically, this gives rise to a new form of German supremacism. Unlike earlier forms rooted in Lebensraum im Osten or notions of German racial superiority over the peoples east of the Oder, this version is grounded in the idea of Germany as the Tätervolk. The Tätervolk has learnt from its crimes, transcended ordinary nationalism, and is instead united by the guilt arising from the atrocities committed in its name.

As a result, Germans are elevated to the status of a post-national moral people, charged with reminding the rest of humanity what is right and wrong, what constitutes a war crime or genocide, and what does not. It is precisely this sense of moral exceptionalism that, in my view, produces this new form of German supremacism.

Consequently, anyone who does not feel at least some degree of inherited guilt for the crimes of their ancestors is regarded as a potential threat. Any attempt to free Germans from their supposed original sin is interpreted as an echo of the same indifference that allegedly enabled the rise of the NSDAP and, ultimately, the Holocaust.

Under this logic, refusing to be ashamed of being German places an individual outside the boundaries of the contemporary German nation because it rejects the very principle upon which that national identity is built.

For those who doubt this assessment, I will now turn to the lyrics of a music video produced by a late-night television host working for German public broadcasting entitled BE DEUTSCH!

Remember, remember
The 9th of November

Broken glass, fire and plot

I know of no reason

Why our very own treason

Should ever be forgot

The 9th of November marks the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989. However, the TV host and singer instead use the date to draw attention to the beginning of the November Pogroms in 1938 and the Hitler Putsch of 1923, both of which occurred on 9 November in their respective years. This even includes the appeal, ‘Why should our very own treason ever be forgotten?’, reinforcing the notion of eternal guilt.

Achtung, germans on the rise
But this time we are fucking nice

Authoritarian nationalist dorks
So tough with your torches and pitchforks

You are not the people, you are the past

The true germans come for you! Better run fast

[…]

Guten Tag, the true germans are here
We are xenophobic's biggest fear

You call for strong leaders, for fences and walls

But being like us takes bigger balls

(Deutsch), we are proud of (deutsch) not being proud
(Deutsch), we are here to (deutsch) remind you

(Deutsch), That we have once been stupid (deutsch), too

We know where assholery leads
You have an election to vote for the best

But we see it more like an IQ-test (You failed)

We've learned our lesson, so take our advice

Hold together, try to be nice and

Deutsch – open, deutsch – multi-cultural
Deutsch – modest, deutsch – help the weak and poor

Deutsch – neighbours, deutsch – tolerant

Deutsch – Grundgesetz, deutsch – Dosenpfand

(Deutsch), say it clear, (deutsch) say it loud

(Deutsch), we are proud of (deutsch) not being proud

(Deutsch), human dignity is (deutsch) unimpeachable

(Deutsch), you will learn, if even (deutsch) we were teachable

Here, the singer engages directly with the post-war national founding myth and what it entails. In the chorus, the German community is defined through the proclamation, ‘We are proud of not being proud [to be German],’ while pride itself is portrayed as the attitude of an outsider who does not belong to the community.

The TV host also addresses apparent fears that are present in the German psyche, primarily the fear of once again losing control and giving in to violent compulsions that some believe are inherent in the German soul.

At the same time, the foreign audience is reminded that Germans have not only learnt from their past and are no longer ‘assholes’ or ‘xenophobic’, but, more importantly, that they now occupy the moral high ground from which they can judge every decision made by others with apparent impunity because they are, after all, the Tätervolk. This form of moral supremacism, fuelled by guilt and endless self-reflection on national identity, is expressed through the promise, ‘You will learn.’ The implication is that, because Germans themselves proved teachable, they are now in a position of moral authority to instruct other nations on what it means to embrace liberal-democratic values and universalism.

The German nation occupies a unique position in its relationship with the past. The industrialised mass murder of millions, alongside the meticulously planned mass executions carried out in Eastern Europe, is certainly unique in terms of its brutality and bureaucratic organisation, although other nations and regimes have also committed atrocities on a comparable scale in terms of the number of victims. Why, then, are Germans so eager not only to acknowledge the crimes of the past but also to demonstrate that they have fundamentally changed?

Turkey provides a useful point of comparison. A Turkish nationalist may claim that the Armenian genocide never happened while simultaneously implying that, even if it did, it was justified. By contrast, although younger Germans are increasingly detached from a past that is now well beyond living memory, the German collective psyche is unlikely ever to free itself entirely from the crimes of the Third Reich. Many Germans regard those crimes as so extraordinary in their scale and singular in world history that they believe they carry an enduring moral responsibility.

A healthy form of German patriotism or nationalism is therefore unlikely to re-emerge. This is due not only to the psychological constraints that continue to shape German political culture but also to the broader transformation of the international order, in which the traditional nation state appears to be losing some of its centrality. An era increasingly defined by civilisational politics may provide Germany with a new role, not merely as an economic powerhouse but, more importantly, as a driving force behind European integration. A Europe led by a Germany burdened by self-doubt, guilt, and persistent hesitation towards militarisation may struggle to meet the challenges of the coming decades. Germany may ultimately prove unable to overcome this psychological barrier on its own. Ironically, it may instead be its European partners who extend a hand, enabling Germany to move beyond both its past and its present and enter a new chapter.
"

Tim Winterling

Tim Winterling

Founder

Ave Europa Germany

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Receive new essays, columns, and papers from The Pan-European Journal straight to your inbox.

Journal of Political Thought sun logoThe Pan-European Journal

Pan-European Magazine affiliated with Ave Europa

Connect