
The Anatomy of Social Trust and the Illusion of Homogeneity
I The Anatomy of Social Trust: A Comparative Analysis between the Anglo-Saxon Model and the Competitive Examination System
The topic of social trust represents one of the most fascinating subjects in sociology, political economy, and evolutionary biology. This concept is not limited to describing an individual character trait, but constitutes the very foundation through which human civilizations organize, cooperate, and thrive. The ability to trust strangers acts as an invisible "lubricant," essential to allow the gears of an entire nation to function smoothly and without friction.
The Anglo-Saxon Reference System and the Value of Reputation
The Anglo-Saxon system of recommendation (or reference letter) represents the key to accessing executive corporate positions or the most prestigious universities. However, this mechanism can function in a virtuous manner only within societies characterized by high trust, social cohesion, and a relative absence of corrupt power hegemony. In such contexts, individual reputation is considered a person's most precious capital.
From a historical perspective, it should be clarified that this model hid an intrinsically elitist reality: those who had the opportunity to study and enter elite social and professional circles belonged almost exclusively to wealthy families. During the Industrial Revolution, access to managerial, academic, or political roles was reserved for a learned few. These environments were so highly selective and exclusive that the vast majority of the most influential thinkers and scientists of the era could, literally, all be immortalized together on a single silver chloride photographic plate. In that context, reputation was everything: recommending a dishonest or unsuitable candidate was equivalent to committing social suicide, which translated into immediate exile from boardrooms and high-society salons.
Analytical extension on the Anglo-Saxon model:
Today, this system has evolved into modern professional networking and the use of professional references. Although it has become more accessible compared to the Victorian period, its logical core remains the same: the reference functions as a form of “delegated trust.” A professional or academic puts their institutional credibility behind a candidate, attesting to intangible qualities such as work ethic, problem-solving ability, and interpersonal skills. The Anglo-Saxon labour market, highly flexible and dynamic, prefers to absorb the risk of a bad hire (easily resolved through dismissal) rather than confining selection to rigid bureaucratic parameters, thereby rewarding trust-based flexibility.
I.I Lee Kuan Yew – Immaterial Values as an Engine of Development
A good historical example of high social trust is offered by Lee Kuan Yew, Singapore’s founding prime minister and central architect of is modern economic development. Shortly after World War II, while studying law at Cambridge University as a young man, he was struck by a scene from ordinary daily life. As he emerged from Piccadilly Circus Underground station in London, he noticed an unattended pile of newspaper on the street. Commuters would take a newspaper, put their payment into an old cardboard box, and, if necessary, take their own change from it. Everything took place without anyone present to monitor the transaction or prevent theft. This great display of honesty and civic discipline impressed the young Lee so deeply that, upon returning home, he resolved to build Singaporean society around similarly rigorous standards of public trust and civic responsibility. He understood that a country’s progress does not depend exclusively on infrastructure or skyscrapers, but draws its strength primarily form the intangible values of its citizens. A society that is not constantly forced to spend time, money, and energy protecting itself against opportunism and theft is a society free to channel those same resources into innovation and economic growth. (Lee Kuan Yew during his studies in England. Source: The Straits Times).
I.II The Evolution of Cooperation in Homogeneous Societies
To understand why some societies develop extraordinarily high levels of cooperation while others remain trapped in a cycle of perpetual suspicion, it is useful to turn to evolutionary biology and evolutionary psychology. Striking examples of exceptional civic cohesion can be found among historically isolated populations, from mountain communities such as the Tibetans to the societies of Scandinavia.
Geographic isolation and social homogeneity help explain this phenomenon. In environments marked by harsh climates, scarce resources, and unforgiving conditions, cooperation did not emerge merely as philosophical ideal, but as an imperative of collective survival. Within small and relatively homogenous communities, where people share traditions, language, and often a common ethnic identity, social control is immediate, personal, and visible. The well-being of the individual is inseparable from that of the group, creating powerful incentives to cooperate and sharply constraining opportunistic behaviour – the so-called free-riding, whereby some benefit from the efforts of others without contributing themselves. Those who refuse to contribute are quickly identified and ostracised, an almost existential form of social punishment in an environment where survival itself depends upon mutual reliance.
Over generations, such patterns of cooperation could become a profound evolutionary and cultural advantage. Social trust and the willingness to contribute gradually became embedded in the moral fabric of these communities, shaping not only social norms but, in some cases, morality and religion themselves. The results is a distinctive equilibrium between individual interests and the needs of the wider community. A revealing historical example can be found in the Protestant work ethic of Northern Europe, famously analysed by Max Weber. Within this tradition, work ceases to be regarded as a burden or a curse, as it had often been portrayed in classical thought, and is elevated instead into a divine blessing – a calling (Beruf). Honest and diligent contribution to the welfare of the community thus acquires a spiritual dimension: work becomes not simply a means of livelihood, but an expression of moral worth and, in the theological imagination of the period, a visible sign of one’s vocation and election.
I.III Francis Fukuyama, Transaction Costs, and Economic Development
While evolutionary biology helps illuminate the origins of trust within isolated communities, political scientist Francis Fukuyama examines its far-reaching consequences for the global economy. In his monumental 1995 work Trust: The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity, Fukuyama radically expands the notion of “capital,” distinguishing between societies according to the depth of their social capital. He broadly divides them into two categories: “high-trust” societies such as Japan, Germany, and the traditional United States, and “low-trust” societies, such as France, Southern Italy, and certain regions of traditional China.
The fundamental dividing line between these two models is the level of transaction costs. In high-trust societies, loyalty and confidence extend beyond the immediate family and can be granted even to complete strangers. This capacity for spontaneous cooperation permits leaner and more flexible forms of economic organisation, in which agreements can often rest on little more than trust and a handshake. Companies are therefore able to transcend the confines of family ownership and entrust their operations to professional managers, laying the foundations for the emergence of large, efficient, and globally competitive corporations. At the same time, a rich and resilient civil society takes root, populated by civic clubs, voluntary associations, professional organisations, and independent corporations.
Low-trust societies, by contrast, tend to produce what Fukuyama describes as “saddle-shaped societies.” Authority is concentrated around two opposing poles: at one end, intense and often unquestioning loyalty to the immediate family; and the other, a powerful and intrusive bureaucratic state. between these two poles lies a vast deficit of trust toward strangers – and, consequently, a weak or fragmented civil society. The economic consequences are substantial. When trust cannot extent beyond the family circle, employing an outside professional becomes an act of calculated risk, and relationships that might otherwise be governed by reputation must instead be secured through lengthy contracts, lawyers, notaries, elaborate regulations, and coercive mechanisms of enforcement. The resulting burden of transaction costs weighs heavily on economic organisation, encouraging a fragmented productive structure dominated by small and medium-seized family enterprises and making it difficult for firms to achieve the economies of scale required to compete on a global level.
The Bureaucratic Alternative: The Competitive Examination Model
Unlike the Anglo-Saxon world, other societies have had to develop different institutional antibodies to contain clientelism – a phenomenon that emerges when “recommendation” loses its virtuous function as a guarantee of competence and degenerates into a mere exchange of favours. It is against this backdrop that, in Italy, the system of public competitive examinations (concorso pubblico) emerged, with the primary aim of limiting nepotistic interference by placing candidates on a formally equal footing through standardised selection procedures.
Despite its ostensibly impartial design, however, the competitive examination system in its current form presents profound limitations. The public examination inevitably trades much of the fiduciary meritocracy and organisational flexibility associated with the Anglo-Saxon model for a rigid bureaucratic framework. Moreover, the attempt to guarantee absolute objectivity inevitably collides with the human subjectivity of examining boards and selectors, particularly in oral examinations. The deeper difficulty lies in the plurality of cultural preference points within a highly heterogenous society such as Italy’s, where establishing evaluation criteria capable of commanding broad and consistent agreement becomes extraordinarily complex. A quality that one evaluator regards as an essential professional or academic virtue may be perceived by another as irrelevant, problematic, or even discriminatory.
Yet within the Italian social structure, the public examination remains, even today, a necessary institutional enterprise – arguably the “lesser evil,” and certainly a more defensible alternative to the arbitrary logic of clientelism. By contrast, societies characterised by greater cultural homogeneity and a stronger degree of institutional consensus, such as China or Japan, may find it easier to establish and apply relatively uniform criteria of evaluation in competitive selection
Analytical extension on the competitive examination system:
The competitive examination model stems from the Weberian legal-administrative tradition, whose fundamental aim is to maintain a clear separation between the political and personal spheres and the administrative sphere. The great strength of this system lies in its constitutional guarantee of equal access; its structural weakness, however, is a form of evaluative “myopia.” Standardised examinations are highly effective at measuring acquired knowledge and the ability to reproduce it under controlled conditions, but they are poorly suited to assessing soft skills, empathy, judgement, and practical aptitude for operational roles. The result can be a persistent mismatch between formal merit and actual effectiveness, contributing to chronic inefficiencies within public administration.
I.IV Imperial China: The Keju (科举) System
The imperial examination system – the Keju – was the pillar of Chinese administration for nearly 1300 years. It was introduced during the Sui Dynasty (581-681 AD), refined under the Tang and Song Dynasties, and definitely abolished only in 1905, shortly before the fall of the Empire.
- The Objective: The primary goal of the Keju was to dismantle the power of the blood aristocracy. The emperor needed officials loyal to him and to the State, rather than to local family clans. Thus was born the class of “mandarins” (or scholar-officials), men whose power derived solely form intellectual merit certified by examination.
- Contents and Standardisation: What did one need to study to pass the exam? Not technical, administrative, or scientific subjects, but the Confucian Classics (the “Four Books and Five Classics”). Under the Ming and Qing Dynasties, the “eight-legged essay” (baguwen) format became mandatory, an extremely rigid rhetorical style. This created incredible cultural homogeneity: form north to south across the cast empire, anyone seeking a career had to internalise and think according to the same Confucian philosophical and moral frameworks. The exam did not merely assess abilities; it guaranteed ideological orthodoxy.
- Social Mobility and the “Social Elevator”: In theory the Keju was open to almost all men, regardless of class (with exclusions for merchants, actors, and criminals in certain areas). The myth of the “poor village boy who came prime minister” was the cornerstone of imperial propaganda. In practice, however, only wealthy families could afford the decades of expensive study required to pass such difficult tests (an obvious parallel with the wealth bias of the historical Anglo-Saxon system).
I.V Present-Day China: The Guokao (国考) and the Gaokao (高考)
Today in China, the legacy of the imperial examinations remains extremely strong and permeates all of society. The obsession with studying and the cult of the exam manifest primarily in two major hurdles: the Gaokao (the university entrance examination) and, regarding the selection of public leadership class, the Guokao (the National Civil Service Examination).
- The Guokao and its Selectivity: The Guokao is the principal examination for entering the central government administration and the Chinese Communist Party. It is considered one of the most competitive exams in the world. Every year, millions of recent graduates compete for a few tens of thousands of positions (often the ratio exceeds 50 or 100 candidates per position, with peaks of thousands of candidates for the most sought-after posts). Passing it means securing the so-called “iron rice bowl” (tie fan wan), namely a stable, prestigious government job with excellent benefits.
- Modern Contents: Unlike the Keju, modern exams evaluate logical-deductive skills, verbal comprehension, data analysis, and problem-solving abilities. However, there is an element of strong continuity with the past. A crucial part of the exam involves knowledge of political theory. In place of Confucius, candidates today must demonstrate a deep mastery of Marxism, the history of the Chinese Communist Party, and, in recent years, “Xi Jingping Thought.” The objective remains the same: selecting brilliant but ideologically aligned bureaucrats.
- Social Control: Exactly as in ancient times, today’s competitive examination system serves as an instrument of stability. It directs the country’s most brilliant and ambitious minds into the administrative organs of the State, rather than leaving them to opposition or dissidence.
The Common Thread
If we compare imperial and present-day China through the lens of that covered above, two key concepts emerge:
1. The Exam as an Instrument of Hegemony: In a system of high homogeneity like China’s, central power holds the authority to establish what is “right” to study. In the Anglo-Saxon system, a person’s worth is established “from below,” through networks of references and social trust. In the Chinese system, both ancient and modern, a person’s worth is certified “from above,” by the State, through a rigorous examination.
2. Ideological Meritocracy: The Chinese examination system has never sought sterile technical neutrality; as the Italian public examination often attempts to do. It has always sought a form of moral and ideological meritocracy. The ideal imperial mandarin or the modern Party official is not merely someone who knows how to administer well, but someone who embodies and defends the core values of the system – Confucianism yesterday, and socialism with Chinese characteristics today.
II The Illusion of Homogeneity: Genetics, Trust, and Institutional Compromise
If the theoretical objective of a State is to achieve a society that adheres homogenously to a common set of rules and values, one must accept the corollary of a monocultural reality. Such a society would need to transcend even regionalisms in order to impose a rigid identity, inevitably resulting in a monoethnic composition characterised by extremely low psychological variability
However, the ethics and mindsets of populations cannot be altered by decree, short of resorting to authoritarian action or drastic social engineering. This can be observed in contemporary authoritarian approaches, such as Nayib Bukele’s zero-tolerance policies in El Salvador, or in historical grand projects of forced homogenisation, such as Peter the Great’s centralising reforms in 18th century Russia or the ruthless cultural, linguistic, and bureaucratic standardisation imposed by China’s first emperor, Qin Shi Huang.
Outside coercive regimes, the only solution for achieving spontaneous and universal adherence to rules would be the paradoxical and unfeasible scenario of eliminating all diversity and replicating a single standardised human model. Given the complete impossibility of ethnic and cultural standardisation, particularly in the Italian peninsula, the State is therefore forced to devise sociological stratagems that translate into institutional compromises, carrying significant structural repercussions.
Biological Heterogeneity and the Italian Genetic Map
Observing the genetic structure and historical isolation of population within the peninsula reveals a picture of extraordinary fragmentation. Genetic cluster analyses, highlighted by PCA (Principal Component Analysis) graphs and haplogroup mapping, demonstrate that Italy is not a biologically homogenous block, but rather an evolutionary mosaic.
As extensively documented by population genetics studies (e.g., Raveane et al., 2019, Science Advances), Italy hosts populations whose biologically and historical distances are comparable to those found between entirely different European nations.
- Northern Italy displays strong genetic affinities with continental and Southwestern Europe, including France, the Iberian Peninsula, and Celtic and Germanic populations.
- Southern Italy and Sicily lie on a genetic and cultural continuum deeply linked to the Eastern Mediterranean, North Africa, and Greece, resulting from millennia of Phoenician, Greek, Arab, and Norman stratifications.
- Sardinia represents an evolutionary chapter of its own, functioning as a genetic isolate that preserves traces of early Neolithic European populations.
This fragmentation is not merely a statistical datum, but the outcome of millennia of geographic barriers – the Alps and Apennines – and reproductive isolation that prevented homogenous admixture across the population.
Beyond Economics: The Behavioural Genetics of the Divide
Often, the divide between different areas of the country is explained exclusively through economic or historical lenses (the industrialisation of the North versus the latifundism of the South). However, modern behavioural genetics and gene-culture coevolution theories (or dual-inheritance theory) offer a much deeper perspective.
Diametrically opposed environmental, climatic, and evolutionary pressures have forged different approaches to resource management, risk tolerance, and affectivity. Populations adapted not only physically, but also psychologically to their environments:
1. The Parasite-Stress Theory of the Italian Case: The phenomenon of deep behavioural divergence finds an illuminating explanation in one of the most fascinating paradigms of modern evolutionary biology and behavioural ecology. As systematically theorised by researchers Corey Fincher and Randy Thornhill, the Parasite-Stress Theory postulates that infectious diseases and parasites present in a given ecosystem played a decisive role in shaping the social, psychological, and value evaluation of human populations. According to this theoretical framework, global macro-differences in family structure, religiosity, and social values are not merely historical or economic contingencies, but represent genuine psychological adaptations developed to cope with the environmental pressures of pathogens.
The Behavioural Immune System and In-Group Assortative Sociality
To fully understand the genesis of distrust, one must analyse the central biological mechanism of the theory: “in-group assortative sociality.” Throughout much of human evolutionary history, in environments characterised by high infectious risk, interaction with strangers (out-groups) consistently carried a potentially fatal bioenergetic cost. Foreign populations or travellers historically carried exotic pathogen strains to which the local community possessed no adequate immune defences.
Consequently, closure to outsiders functioned as a vital behavioural “immunological shield,” a true extension of the physiological immune system. Fincher and Thornhill demonstrate that this human defensive strategy articulates and manifests through three interconnected behaviours: philopatry (the tendency not to disperse and to reproduce within the narrow native territory), ethnocentrism (favouritism, absolute loyalty, and nepotism toward in-group members), and xenophobia (active avoidance and pervasive suspicion toward strangers).
The Mezzogiorno Laboratory: Malaria and Evolutionary Pressure
Applying this rigorous theoretical lens to the heterogeneity of the Italian peninsula, the North-South sociological divide takes on the contours of a precise evolutionary divergence. Vast areas of Southern Italy, coastal regions, the major islands were continuously endemic reservoirs of devastation infectious diseases from antiquity until the first half of the 20th century. Malaria (caused by lethal parasites of the genus Plasmodium), in particular, exerted brutal and prolonged selective pressure in these territories. In an ecosystem afflicted by constant “pathogen stress,” biology and gene-culture coevolution rewarded communities that were structurally capable of isolating themselves.
Avoidance of “outsiders” – unconsciously perceived as carriers of disease or silent threats to the local bio-social equilibrium – and extremely strong attachment to the family unit became the only practical survival strategy. Naively trusting travellers or loosening the protective network (immunological, material, and psychological) of the family clan to open up to the outside world meant exposing oneself to very high risks of mortality or reproductive failure.
From Biological Necessity to Cultural Sedimentation
Over countless generations, this biological urgency crystallised into deep-rooted social institutions and cultural values. Behavioural genetics documents how societies historically burdened by high pathogen loads invariably develop stricter social norms, marked conformism, and an ethic oriented exclusively toward their own in-group. Conversely, in territories or climatic zones where pathogen pressure is structurally lover (such as colder, alpine, or Northern European climates) – where the lethal cost of contagion are lower than the benefits of commercial and cultural exchange with the outside – one observes the spontaneous emergence of individualism, and above all, “generalised trust” toward strangers and institutions.
This scientific perspective compels the reader to deeply re-examine the Italian social fabric. Behavioural phenomena often dismissed by classical sociology as markers or irremediable “backwardness” – extreme familism, in-group clientelism, or chronic distrust toward the State (which represents the institutional and abstract out-group par excellence) – are not trivial moral flaws stemming from poverty or foreign rule. They reveal themselves, on the contrary, as imposing evolutionary scars: once-lifesaving adaptive strategies that, despite having sedimented at the level of behavioural genetics struggle to disengage within the modern, yet biologically recent, framework of the unified State.
2. Polymorphisms and Adaptation: Recent studies have explored how the frequencies of certain genetic polymorphisms vary geographically in response to specific environmental pressures, a biological phenomenon known as “gene-culture coevolution.” Analysis of genetic data across the Italian population has demonstrated clear and measurable genetic distinctions within the peninsula, particularly along the North-South axis. These divergences, however, are not limited solely to historical ancestry markers but also involve genetic variants affecting neural systems and neurotransmitter pathways, which may influence social behaviour, novelty seeking, conformism, and risk perception.
The Serotonin Gene (5-HTTLPR) and Defensive Collectivism
An exemplary case is presented by the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTTLPR).
- Pioneering research by Chiao and Blizinsky on gene-culture coevolution highlighted that collectivist cultures show significantly higher frequencies of the “short” allele of this specific gene.
- At a biological level, this allele is closely associated with greater emotional sensitivity and heightened stress reactivity.
- In historically threatening environments or those characterised by high pathogen prevalence, collectivist cultural values evolved to function as a buffer.
- This introverted, group-focused social structure aims to protect genetically more susceptible populations, reducing the incidence of affective disorders and ensuring cohesion in the face of external threats.
Dopamine (DRD4) and Risk Propensity
In parallel, the dopamine D4 receptor (DRD4) plays a crucial role in human behavioural plasticity, although it is important to emphasise that human behaviour is often multifactorial and must be contextualised within its specific setting.
- The 7-rpeat allele (7R) of the DRD4 gene is strongly associated with the personality trait of novelty seeking.
- Medical literature also links this same allele to attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and impulsive behaviours.
- From an evolutionary standpoint, studies that the 7R allele originated as a rare mutation and subsequently spread through human populations via positive selection.
- Evolutionists hypothesise that individuals carrying traits related to hyperactivity, novelty seeking, and perseverance were precisely those who led major migrations, technological innovation, and human expansion into new and uncertain territories.
Life History Theory: "Fast" vs "Slow" Strategies in the Italian Context
The interaction between the expression of these genetic traits and the surrounding environment finds its ultimate explanatory synthesis in Life History Theory.
- This theory from behavioural ecology suggests that psychological and behavioural variations depend on how organisms unconsciously allocate their resources throughout their lifespan.
- In harsh and unpredictable environments, where mortality is uncertain and life expectancy is perceived as limited, individuals tend to adopt “fast life-history strategies.”
- Fast strategies manifest through specific psychological traits, such as impulsivity, a high propensity for risk-taking, a short-term planning horizon, and an adaptive need to seek constant stimulation, even to escape boredom.
- From a biological perspective, these unpredictable environments favour early reproduction and multiple partnerships rather than prioritizing long-term development and heavy parental investment.
- Conversely, stable, rich, and safe ecosystems permit the adoption of “slow life-history strategies,” which privilege long-term development, future planning, and the gradual accumulation of resources.
- It is nonetheless important to note that multiple factors contribute to determining a population’s behavioural patterns, and that these factors coexist and interact.
- Psychological Diversity and the Social Trust Crisis: This deep-rooted biological distance, combined with cultural coevolution, translates into marked psychological variability, culminating in a dramatic collapse of social capital.
- Fragmented Trust and Amoral Familism: In such a heterogeneous territory, generalized trust toward “strangers” collapses. In vast areas of the country, a mindset prevails – defined by sociologist Edward Banfield as “amoral familism” – where solidarity, adherence to rules, and ethics are reserved almost exclusively for the immediate family or local circle (in-group). The State and broader society (out-group) are viewed with chronic distrust, as alien or predatory entities.
- Behavioural Ethics: Adherence to norms in such a fragmented country is rarely internalized as a universal civic pact, a phenomenon evident in homogeneous and biologically compact Scandinavian societies. On the contrary, rules are often perceived as external coercive impositions, to be disregarded or bypassed as soon as the direct enforcement mechanism lapses.
- Italian regional differences in social capital and trust can be interpreted as the outcome of a historical process of path dependence in which institutions, environment, infectious diseases, family structure, and culture mutually influenced one another. The genetic component can be considered a possible element of the gene-culture coevolution process, although this field of study remains heavily debated within the scientific community and its hypotheses await further verification.
The Impact on Selection Systems
This profound biological, psychological, and value-based heterogeneity provides the ideal lens through which to understand the structural failures and necessities of recruitment and administrative systems.
The Short-Circuit of the Anglo-Saxon Model – The reference system (or fiduciary networking) relies on very high social cohesion and generalized trust. If imported into a psychologically and biologically fractured context – where two citizens of the same nation possess diametrically opposed value systems, family structures, and expressions of trust – this model inevitably collapses. The reference loses its value as an “ethical guarantee,” which is rooted in reputation within a cohesive community, and degrades into nepotism and clientelism. Biologically speaking, it becomes a tool of kin selection aimed at protecting and advantaging one’s own in-group at the expense of rival factions.
The Public Competitive Examination as a Sociological Stratagem – In light of this irreconcilable structural divide, the Italian competitive examination model (concorso pubblico) proves to be precisely the institutional compromise mentioned earlier. The public exam is a desperate (and inevitably rigid, rote, and bureaucratic) attempt to impose artificial homogeneity on a country that naturally lacks it. Unable to rely on an internalized civic pact, the exam acts as a mechanical arbiter. Historically, it was designed to offset the total absence of spontaneous trust between individuals who, despite sharing the same political and linguistic borders, inhabit deeply – and perhaps irremediably – different cultural, psychological, and genetic universes.
Originally written in Italian and translated by Archimedes.

Archimedes
Guest WriterAve Europa Italy



